Dinniman: State Government "At War with Public Schools"

The Democratic senator came to Spring-Ford's school board meeting.

Senator Andrew Dinniman (D-PA 19) didn't mince words while speaking to the Spring-Ford Area School District board and its audience at Monday night's meeting.

In speaking about charter schools and the issues they cause for public schools, Dinniman said, "What you have is a governor and a legislature at war with public schools."

Dinniman said there is strong support for charter schools in the state government. He co-sponsored Senate Bill 1115, which lays out guidelines for charter schools. 

Several board members have been outspoken on the subject of charter schools because the district is required to pay the charter school for each student that attends. 

Essentially, the taxpayers are paying for students that don't use the distrcit's public schools - they attend charter or cyber-charter schools.

"Charter schools will cost us two million dollars in 2013-2014," said board president Thomas DiBello. 

DiBello also pointed out that the money to pay the charter schools comes from the district taxpayers.

Despite passing the State Senate, SB1115 died in the House and will have to be introduced again in January.

Dinniman, who is the minority chair of the Senate Education Committee, said that the bill was the best bipartisan compromise that the committee members could create. 

The bill had several changes from previous versions. The committee removed language that would allow a statewide board to authorize charter schools. It also contained provisions for more transparency under Right-to-Know and Sunshine Act laws, monitoring academic quality and handling fund surpluses.

Statewide authorization, as it is called, would have taken away a local school district's ability to have any say in the formation of a charter school in its district. 

Requiring charter schools to submit to Sunshine Act provisions allows for more monitoring of their finances as well as their academic process.

Board member Edward Dressler asked why the bill had been attached to a bill concerning special education. 

Dinniman said that combining bills is a common occurrence and that it speeds up the process. 

The special education part of the bill will be separated from the charter school portion when the bill is reintroduced, Dinniman said. 

"I was at the PSBA (Pennsylvania School Board Association) [meeting] last week, and many people would have supported the special education part of the bill," Dressler said. 

Board member Bernard Pettit asked Sen. Dinniman directly if he voted for the bill. 

"I voted for the bill because I thought it was the best compromise we could get," Dinniman answered. 

If reelected in November, Dinniman promised to keep working on school issues. 

"I will work with you to save public education in this state," Dinniman said. 

Tom Giordano October 23, 2012 at 10:03 AM
If public scholls did a good job at education, they shouldn't have to worry about competition from charter schools. Hey Dinniman,get out of the way of what the people of Pennsylvania want, not what school boards and teachers unions want.
Mad as hell... October 23, 2012 at 03:57 PM
I have to agree with Tom. It seems to me that the teachers union doesn't care about actual education...just gouging the taxpayers.
Stephen Eickhoff October 23, 2012 at 04:52 PM
'"Charter schools will cost us two million dollars in 2013-2014," said board president Thomas DiBello. DiBello also pointed out that the money to pay the charter schools comes from the district taxpayers.' Well, duh. So does the money to pay the public schools-- with school taxes increasing at a rate far above household incomes, I might add. Conspicuously absent is proof that it costs more to educate a student at a charter school. If it costs the same or less, then the public schools have no reason to complain, right? WRONG. More butts in seats means more demands by the teacher unions and bigger salaries for the administrators.
SMYRNA-X October 23, 2012 at 05:15 PM
If springford would like to keep thier students in public school, respond to the parents. Get to the bottom of issues and solve them. No its easier to put legislative roadblocks to these rouge families. Try going to anyone in that district with a problem or idea. Teachers and principles are not empowered to make changes in thier classrooms or schools. Middle level supervisors are clueless and push responsiblity to someone else. Leadership from super and ass super guided by what they legally have to do, nothing more. Good luck with a school board member. They focus almost entirely only money. No leadership top to bottom. Except to change good, effective leg and raise taxes.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »